Showing posts with label Medical Musings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medical Musings. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

A few lessons from a short observer stint at a German hospital

In the first few weeks of September, I had the opportunity to visit a well-known hospital in Stuttgart, to spend a few hours each day, "observing" the system. Not knowing the language, was a drawback for me, impeding any medical knowledge from coming my way. However, it was a chance to learn a few basic things about the "system" and how it works here. Here are some of the things I would love to implement back home.

Keep bedside discussions away from the bedside!


In India, bedside rounds were nearly always, a tedious affair. Doctors would crowd around the patient to discuss the progress (or sometimes the lack of it). The poor patient would lie in the midst of this mob-like discussion of the facts of his/her case, often having to listen to the dismal details of their condition. Moreover, if the resident in-charge was to be reprimanded for any of his/her errors, it would be done right there, in the full galore of all the ward patients!. I always wondered if this entire exercise was necessary or if we could do it in a better way.

Seems there is a better way. Here, the case discussions are done in the doctor's room, before the real meeting between the head doctor and the patient. The resident doctor does his/her clinical rounds before the discussion. Then, they all sit it out in the doctors room, before their electronic gadgets, going over all the patients details. All lab data is just a click away [no need for the resident to memorize (or be tempted to lie about!) nitty numbers!]. The nurse in-charge of the patient is also party to the discussion and often provides valuable inputs on symptoms and complaints. It is a relaxed and mature discussion. It is more fruitful for the patient as his/her case is better discussed and analyzed.


Access technology/ resources when making clinical decisions


Having the discussion in the doctors room, also has the advantage of being able to access valuable information related to individual clinical decisions, at the click of a button or at the hand's stretch (at the book library). Doctors can't keep everything in their head. Using technology effectively and in timely manner is important.


Keep bedside visits pleasant and comforting


Having taken care of the clinical details of the case, the bedside visit is now focussed on exchanging pleasantries with the patient. The patient is more comfortable with the talk directed to him/her rather than between the doctors in-charge. I have often felt, that we don't do this enough in India.

Talk to the nurses


After the discussion and bedside rounds are done with, the resident's task is to call on the nurses and instruct them in a clear format what is to be done for their patients on that day. Everything is written and undersigned by the doctor and the in-charge nurse!. Here, the nurse's role is supreme- in fact she is the primary care-giver here who co-ordinates all the orders.

In India, nurses are given a raw deal. We never really acknowledge them as equals. Of course, in many cases, nurses are not really inclined to work!. But this mature interaction between the doctor and nurse, is something that needs to be emulated.

Patient information sheets for every intervention


Before any intervention, the doctor and nurse, arm the patient with a superbly descriptive patient information sheet, written in a language the patient and family can understand. This is given to the patient well before the time of the procedure. The patients are required to sign the form, as having consented to the procedure, having understood the risks.

Back home. we vaguely describe the procedure (orally!) and take a hasty consent (if at all!). This needs to change.


Acknowledge the primary treating physician


In the discharge sheet of every patient, the primary referring physician is sincerely acknowledged.  A detailed story of the patient's stay at the hospital is written down for their reference.

Very rarely, do we in India, even turn the pages of the case file to see who has referred this patient to us!. Networking is everything.

Have a summary sheet out front which reads like a biography


It only takes 5 minutes to get acquainted with any new case in the wards here. Everything in the patient's medical history is neatly typed out on a summary sheet placed on the front of the file, which is complete with dates and events.


Ward design and care


Cleanliness is one thing; but, having a beautifully designed ward is another thing altogether!. Its amazing how comforting, for any visitor/patient, a brightly lit ward with colorful pieces of art and windows streaming in sunshine, can feel like.

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Holiday Fever

This has been one tough month.. started out on a really low note!.. and then was really stressed out for most of the time.. haven't shopped once(!) this entire month.. for the first time ever, am doing back-to-back night shifts, which are only making my dark circles darker!.. haven't watched as many movies as i usually do.. and to top it all.. i haven't made my three-weekly visit to the parlour, as a result of which, i'm feeling like a bear! Wheeew!
Finally today, actually feeling a bit relaxed, but wish i could have made it for my cousin's wedding this weekend (haven't decked up for an occasion in ages!).. but feeling guilty about taking off more days from work!..
Just the sheer fact that i can look forward to a holiday tomorrow is keeping me in good spirits. Its really too bad that doctors suffer from a holiday-deficit. I really envy my friends working in corporate houses, who live the typical 5 day/week work schedule with weekends off!..come Saturday, and they are all making plans for the weekend- Dandeli/ Goa etc.
Doctors, on the other hand, would be lucky to be exempted for Sunday rounds or duty!..we are expected to be committed towards duty 24X7.
Anyway, not really complaining, because in reality, i miss my work, when i'm away from it too long.. and sometimes even two days is too long!

Monday, February 15, 2010

Modern Day Slavery!

Compulsory rural service for all medical students is soon going to be made into law with effect from the next academic year. I really empathize with all those unfortunate M.B.B.S students who are going to be subjected to this meaningless activity, in the name of "service".
Why meaningless?.. because its plain stupidity to expect a hapless, untrained medico, fresh out of M.B.B.S to be the backbone of healthcare for all the rural folk in this country. In short, we are taking our most inexperienced medical personnel to serve 75% of the Indian population!. That amounts to majority of our population being under-serviced as far as health care goes!. There is a clear discrimination of policy when it comes to tackling urban and rural healthcare. Even the proposed 4 year Master of Rural Health (MRH) is a clear violation of the rights of rural citizens to equitable health care like there urban counterparts.
Most of all, it is the poor medico who is going to be worst affected by these thoughtless rules. Not only is he called to serve in an environment of poor infrastructure, he has to sacrifice ties with his family, work for paltry sums of salary to get his degree.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Health Care Reform


Healthcare in India is an industry in want of good management. The onus of providing this precious service has been divided between the private and public institutions. The public institutions are overburdened, under-financed, and notoriously mismanaged. The private institutions cannot claim to be any better. Although they provide a better work culture, they are famous for over pricing and over-investigating.
The poorest of the poor are always the worse affected by these policies. Disregarded by the government hospitals and drained of all savings by the private hospitals they are at the receiving end at all times.
The government in some states, has taken steps to fund the expenses of healthcare for BPL families by providing health packages. Although well intentioned, this is like most government policies is bereft of forethought for possible repercussions. An old adage summarizes this policy- "give a man a fish, and you feed him for a day; teach a man to fish, and you have feed him for a lifetime". Anything handed out on a platter, for grabs, is always ignored for value. Anything worked for or fought for is valued beyond its true price.
These schemes are also exploited by many- some who use it to obtain free healthcare not appropriate for their income, some who pocket money meant for medicines/services rendered and others who take kickbacks for referring the poor souls to an institution that would ultimately benefit from the ingress of money to its coffers.
No scheme involving large amounts of money can be adequately insulated in India from corruption. Unless we incorporate good work ethos and eliminate poverty- which cannot ever happen overnight- we are slaves to corruption!
How then, can we hope to implement better health care to our masses?
Instead of putting lump sums of money into schemes that concentrate on referral and private/public tertiary care setups, we must build around a three-tier system of healthcare with most of the finances and maximum emphasis on the base of the pyramid- the rural health care centres and district healthcare centers. A large chunk of problems can be tackled by these setups itself- if adequately staffed and equipped. Private setups in the rural areas must be encouraged- with incentives such as tax-free holidays (on the lines of IT companies); these centers must be monitored for quality of care by independent responsible observers. Medical colleges must be ordered to adopt a district level hospital and dispense the required heath care to all subjects in that district. Tele-conferencing between district level physicians and those at the tertiary care center must be offered for counselling regarding difficult to treat cases. Unless this kind of infrastructure is in place, it would be meaningless to deploy fresh medical graduates in the grass root centers by compulsion.
Private and public hospitals in two-tier and three-tier cities must be the next target of the government health policies. Only by reducing the burden (by diverting simple-to-treat case to the district level) on these institutions first, can we begin their reconstruction. Strict monitoring of health services dispensed must be undertaken to ensure quality care.
The final priority of the government must be the public institutions in the metros. These must focus primarily on specialized services and advanced training. Soaps and services must parallel the private healthcare setups to be able to survive the economics of the times.



Monday, April 20, 2009

The Longevity Equation: Sex+Sleep=Long Life



Blue Zones..wondering what they are?.. well they are small geographical pockets inhabited by the world's longest lived populations. Here, they tell me, are the maximum number of people over 90, living in one place!.
Scientists think the key to long life might be garnered by the study of these populations.In fact, an extensive study is ongoing to derteminine how these pockets of populations live as long as they do.
Check out this link to know more...

Presently, life expectency in India is 62 years.. slightly more in females than males. A study showed that most health related costs in a person's life are in the last few years of his/her life. A huge amount of money is spent with little respite from the persistent suffering. 
The longeviety quest (as the study is called) is currently focussed on a tiny Greek island of Ikaria.
Here, they believe water from the hot springs might help  relieve joint pains/skin problems.Also, low levels of radon have been detected in the region- making scientists question if low levels of radiation might actually repair damaged DNA! And of course,people here susbide on a Mediterraen diet- which is well known for its health benefits. A locally made honey, drawn by bees from the pollen of thyme, has been attributed anti-oxidant and anti-senility activites!
The best part about the island is the character of the people. Although they have volcanic tempers, they supposedly, quickly subside!. They sleep at  midnight, wake up late and take frequent naps in between.  And here is the absolute winner- even people over 90! are sexually active!!
So the logical conclusion that scientists have drawn from the facts is-  SEX+SLEEP=LONG LIFE!!
In short, their analysis has 9 factors which are believed to be the secrets to a long and health life...
1.stop eating when you are about 80% full
2.Eat more veggies, less protein/processed foods
3.drink red wine in moderation!
4.have a sense of purpose in life
5. maintain a spiritual and belief system
6.Work less*** slow down and take vacations
7.make physical movement a vital part of life
8. have a healthy social network- in fact, having at least 2 good friends is suppose to add years to your life
9. make family a priority.

Sunday, April 19, 2009

SOS from Medicos.. Is anybody listening???


While talking to a set of young freshly passed out batch of medicos who had just completed their MBBS, i could sense their disillusionment with their choice of a career. While their IT schoolmates were earning lumpsums, they were getting peanuts in terms of salary and had to grind their books overtime now if they were aiming for a post graduate seat.I too went through the same emotions at that stage and so did many of my friends. 
There are many problems with the way medical education is imparted in India. When i ask around my medical friends circles, what they would like to change about medical education, i am flooded with a volley of ideas!. Its a pity, no body up there is listening!
Here are a few interesting ideas from people who had "been there. done that"...
  • Many doctors agree that 5and a 1/2 year course (invariably 6!) for MBBS is a waste of time.(Now there is even talk of another year- for a rural posting!). The entire course can be cut short by at least a year- taking off 6 months in 2nd year (Patho/Phrm/MicrB/FM) and another 6months in 3rd year (ENT/Ohpl/SPM). Even the truncated 4 and 1/2 year would drag on for 5 years.. taking the slow rate of admissions to the courses and examination schedules!
  • In fact most doctors feel direct MD degree (maybe then the 5 and 1/2 year course is warrented!) is the need of the hour rather than a preliminary MBBS degree. This will reduce the burden on students preparing for MD entrances.
  • Diplomas must be abolished and all degrees must be given as Masters only. It will save the poor diploma holder the discrimination he/she will face in the job front.
  • After MD medicos must be encouraged to work  and gain in experience rather than slogging it off in college libraries over entrances!. Why don't we have Campus placements in medicine? Hospitals must hire on campus. The salary and perks must be on par with any fresh graduate from a professional stream which is sadly lacking here.
  • Personally Im one for rural medical service. But with the pathetic state of health centers in the periphery, I don't think freshly passed out medicos are the best answer to improving health care in rural areas. And making it compulsory for them in order to obtain their degrees, amounts to exploitation! Instead the service should be voluntary with incentives greater than what one can expect in the cities- like a sponsered fellowship program at the end of 2 years of rural service. Also, these facilities must be linked up by telemedicine units to a head hospital where all experts reside- so that speacialized consltation can be availed of when needed.  Needless to say, PHCs (Primary health centers) must be transformed on the lines of well equipped mini-nursing homes!.
  • Spealization is a must nowadays with the explosion of information, leaving no single individual a master of the whole of medicine. Specialization courses must be need based- there is no point having umpteen number of seats for say OBG, if the jobs are already saturated. Yes, we have a dismal doctor to population ratio in India, but part of the reason is poor dispersion of healthcare to all areas. And of course, the number of seats per field must be updated on a regular basis.
  • Now the biggest hurdle that a medico needs to cross is the entrance exams for getting INTO a post graduate course. Why is this so tough? Because the number of MBBS seats far out number the number of MD seats. So in effect, its a rat race out there!. Well there are 2 solutions for this-1. The logical solution would be to increase the number of post graduate seats within the limits of the need based approach, in propotion to the MBBS seats (because everyone needs to speacialize in medicine in the future!)-this will ensure that everyone gets a post graduate seat but still leaves the rat race open to choices of seat. so the other solution is 2. Scrap the entrances as a whole. Follow a fellowship pattern for speacializtion. Allow the doctor to work in an institute with that speacialization for a minimum period of time .. say 3 years.. and then test is/her acumen at the end of the period both theoretically and practically (includes monitored surgeries!) before awarding him/her the degree. If the institute traing is on par with the degree requirements, the candidate is sure to pass.. if not he/she should be asked to reappear for the test. (no need to regulate the number persons in training for that spealization.
  • Do you have any suggestions to improve the medical education in this country? Fill me in!

I believe in..

My photo
"Twenty years from now, you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than the ones you did.So, throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbor. Let the trade winds in. Explore. Dream. Enjoy."